Journal
ArticleNovember 22, 2026

Andromeda counts angles, not ads

How Meta's retrieval engine picks your ads, why a new reason to buy beats a new cut, and AG1's angle map vs IM8.

Meta's Andromeda decides which of your ads get a shot at each person. Here is why a new angle beats a new cut, AG1's angle map vs IM8, and a free Claude skill to map any brand's angles.

By Adam Raz

CRO · Ex-Meta · Published

12 min readMeta AndromedaCreative anglesClaude skillsAG1

Meta's ad retrieval engine decides which of your ads even get a shot at each person. Fifty versions of the same argument are, in practice, one ad. A new angle is a new reason to buy, and a new chance to reach a different person. Here is how Andromeda works, what AG1's angle mix looks like in Adge data, and a free Claude skill that maps the angles in any brand's ads.

Thousands

Ads kept per person, from millions

1B+ / sec

Ads scored (2026 system)

+2.4%

Facebook conversions since 2025

12

Angles in the skill

What Andromeda changed

Andromeda is Meta's machine learning system for the first stage of ad delivery: retrieval. The 2024 version replaced rule-based shortcuts with a deep model and a hierarchical index of ad clusters. The 2026 version goes further: it scores every eligible ad, using a mixture of specialised user "experts" that a gating network routes each ad to.

Stage 1

Retrieval (Andromeda)

From every ad a person is eligible for, pick a few thousand candidates in milliseconds. If your ad is not picked here, ranking never sees it.

Stage 2

Ranking

Larger models (GEM on Meta's side) predict how likely this person is to act on each candidate and what it is worth.

Stage 3

Auction

Bid, predicted value and ad quality decide which ad is shown.

10,000x

Retrieval model capacity, Dec 2024

+8%

Ads quality on selected segments, 2024

100x

Faster than the 2024 system, Oct 2026
Why it matters for creative

With broad targeting and Advantage+, retrieval reads the ad itself (visuals, words, voice) to decide who it is relevant to. Your creative is now your targeting signal. If your ads all say the same thing, they all signal the same person.

What Meta's October 2026 engineering notes add

Every eligible ad gets scored

Meta says the new system "scores every eligible ad" at near ranking-level quality. Near-duplicates are not thrown out. Each one is scored, but they score almost the same for the same people, so they compete for one audience instead of opening new ones Inference.

Many user experts, not one profile

The user side is an ensemble of specialised towers built from engagement history, cohorts, LLM-derived semantic features and cross-surface signals, aimed at interests that are "diverse, time-evolving, and contextualized". A gating network routes each ad to the most relevant experts. Distinct angles give it distinct things to route Inference.

The pool is flooded with variants

Meta credits generative AI tools with "hundreds of millions of new ads". When everyone can make 50 cuts of an ad, cuts stop being an edge. A different reason to buy still is Inference.

No advice in the post

The engineering post makes no creative recommendations; it reports +2.4% Facebook conversions since 2025. The advice to diversify creative comes from Meta's marketing guidance, below.

What Meta says vs what the industry says

A lot of Andromeda advice is confident and unsourced. This is the line between what Meta has said and what practitioners infer.

ClaimSourceHow to treat it
Retrieval narrows tens of millions of ads to a few thousand per requestMeta Engineering, 2024 and 2026Fact
The 2026 system scores every eligible ad, routing each to specialised user expertsMeta Engineering, Oct 2026Fact
Creative diversification gets the best resultsMeta guidance in its Andromeda materialsOfficial guidance
Ads that lean into different pain points and personas let the system learn who responds to eachMeta business blog, Apr 2025Official guidance
Guidance is outcome based, not model specific: diversify, test, let the system optimiseMeta spokesperson to Marketing BrewFact
Similar ads share one "Entity ID" and one ticket to the auctionPractitioners and tool vendorsUseful model, not a documented Meta field
Above a 60% similarity score ads collapse into one entityThird-party blogsUnverified. Do not plan around a number

Read the vendor claims as a mental model: near-duplicates compete with each other. The exact mechanics and thresholds are not public.

Angle, not ad

Most teams count ads. Some count concepts. Andromeda rewards a level above both: the angle, the single argument an ad makes for why this person should buy. Everything below the angle is execution, and execution changes rarely move an ad into new territory.

01 · Persona

Who it is for

A GLP-1 user worried about losing muscle

02 · Angle

The argument for buying now

Medication cuts appetite, so you need complete nutrition in one scoop

03 · Concept

The story that carries it

A health coach shows her GLP-1 morning routine

04 · Execution

Format, creator, hook, edit

9:16 UGC: "On a GLP? This is your new best friend."

You changedNew angle?Why
The hook lineNoSame argument, new first 2 seconds. Worth testing, but it is iteration.
The creator or actorNoSame argument in a new face. Often clusters with the original.
Format or cropNoPlacement coverage, not a new reason to buy.
The problem it solvesYesDifferent pain, different person.
The moment it matters (GLP-1, travel, new parent)YesA different situation makes it relevant to different people.
The proof (expert, customer, celebrity)UsuallyCounts if the proof is the point of the ad.
The offerSometimesOffer-led ads are an angle. Ten welcome-kit ads are one angle.
The one-sentence test

Write the ad's argument as one sentence with the product name removed. If the sentence is the same as another ad's, it is the same angle, however different the ads look.

Do different personas need different angles?

Mostly yes. Retrieval matches a person to an ad by what the ad is about. A bloated 30-year-old and a 55-year-old on GLP-1 medication are both AG1 prospects, but they are moved by different arguments. One angle can only be the best match for so many people.

Where you need a different angle

When the reason to buy differs: a different problem, moment or objection. GLP-1 users need "protect muscle and nutrients"; travellers need "keep the routine when you leave home".

Where one angle carries many personas

When the reason is universal and strong (a great offer, a simple routine). Vary the persona in the execution and keep the argument. AG1's "simplify the stack" ideas do this and last longest.

Devil's advocate

More angles is not automatically better. Each angle needs spend to learn. Ten thin angles on a small budget can lose to three strong ones.

AG1's angle map

We pulled AG1's Meta ads from Adge Nexus for the last 90 days and compared them with IM8, its closest challenger. Adge tags every idea with an angle description and a persona; Claude, connected to Adge, sorted those descriptions into the skill's 12-angle taxonomy.

3,006

AG1 ideas in 90 days

3,429

IM8 ideas in 90 days

6.1

AG1 effective angles

5.3

IM8 effective angles

33%

AG1 ads on value & offer

57%

AG1 ads in top 3 angles

12%

AG1 ideas with no clear angle

6.5

AG1 ads per idea (sample)

Share of ads by angle

Meta · 25 Aug to 22 Nov 2026 · 250 most-versioned ideas per brand
AG1IM8 (main competitor)
Value & offer
33.3%
36.9%
Life moment
13.3%
4.5%
No clear angle
10.1%
11.3%
Simplify the stack
8.5%
5.7%
Sensory & format
7.7%
1.1%
Identity & performance
6.1%
10.1%
Authority & science
5.8%
8.6%
Celebrity & ambassador
4.7%
0.6%
Us vs them
4.5%
4%
Problem & pain
3.5%
11.1%
Social proof
2.6%
6.1%
Angle (AG1)IdeasAdsShare of adsAds per ideaMedian days liveLive 30+ daysIM8 share
Value & offer8454133.3%6.417.542%36.9%
Life moment2521713.3%8.71940%4.5%
No clear angle2916510.1%5.73655%11.3%
Simplify the stack251388.5%5.55064%5.7%
Sensory & format191257.7%6.61542%1.1%
Identity & performance18996.1%5.55572%10.1%
Authority & science14945.8%6.73357%8.6%
Celebrity & ambassador13764.7%5.83862%0.6%
Us vs them9734.5%8.12122%4%
Problem & pain7573.5%8.14357%11.1%
Social proof7422.6%62843%6.1%
Read 1 · Both lead with the deal

A third of AG1's ads (33%) and 37% of IM8's argue on price, bundles and free gifts Data. A dozen welcome-kit ads are close to one ad to retrieval. The offer is not the problem; running it as the main angle is Inference.

Read 2 · AG1 owns angles IM8 ignores

Life moments (GLP-1, travel, military), taste and format, and celebrity carry 26% of AG1's ads vs 6% of IM8's Data. These likely reach people IM8's ads do not Inference.

Read 3 · AG1 under-invests in the problem

IM8 puts 11% of ads on a specific problem (gut, energy, sleep) and 10% on performance identity. AG1 puts 3.5% on problem-led ads Data. That is AG1's clearest white space Inference.

Basis: Adge Nexus, Meta public ad library, 25 Aug to 22 Nov 2026. Sample: each brand's 250 most-versioned ideas (AG1 1,627 ads, IM8 3,102 ads), so ads per idea is higher than the brand-wide figure. Angle labels: Claude classification of Adge's per-idea angle descriptions; 10 of the 12 labels were detected (Desire & outcome and Objection buster need the full ad text). Effective angles = 1 / sum of squared ad shares. Days live is a proxy for a winner, not proof. No spend data exists for competitors.

Where AG1 versions hardest, ideas die fastest

The pattern the skill flags: angles where a brand makes many versions of each idea, but the ideas do not stay live. That is volume going into variants retrieval likely treats as one ad.

AG1 angle sliceIdeasAds per ideaMedian days liveLive 30+ days
GLP-1 and weight-loss medication119.9120 of 11
Bloating and digestion109.5133 of 10
All 250 sampled ideas2506.528n/a
Simplify the stack255.55064%
Identity & performance185.55572%
What this says

AG1 makes about 10 versions of each GLP-1 and bloating idea, then retires them in under two weeks. It makes about 5 versions of its simplicity and performance ideas, which stay live 50+ days Data. The timely angles are being versioned, not re-angled. The fix is new arguments inside the GLP-1 persona (protein and muscle, nausea and taste, cost vs separate supplements), not more cuts of the same one Inference.

AG1's persona spread

Adge tags each ad with the persona it speaks to. Across AG1's 2,994 tagged ads in the window, ten personas each get at least 5% of creative. One persona, the overwhelmed supplement skeptic, gets more than a fifth.

AG1 share of tagged ads by persona

Meta · 25 Aug to 22 Nov 2026 · Adge persona tags
Overwhelmed supplement skeptic
22.2%
High performer chasing consistency
11.7%
Wellness newcomer seeking momentum
9.5%
Flavor-wary wellness skeptic
7.9%
Frequent traveler fighting disruption
7.1%
Cost-conscious wellness subscriber
6.9%
Gut health comfort seeker
6.9%
Daily nutrition simplifier
6.7%
GLP-1 user protecting strength
6.4%
Exhausted parent running on empty
6.3%
Midlife energy reclaimer
4%
Sleep and nighttime personas (3 tags)
0.7%
Read

AG1 runs a defined set of about ten personas Data. The gap is depth, not breadth: midlife energy (4%) and sleep (under 1%) are thin, while IM8 puts 7% of its ads on its "midlife adult fighting decline" persona alone Data.

Caution on persona counts

IM8 shows 63 persona tags to AG1's 20, but persona labels are generated per brand, so the count partly reflects how finely they were split. Compare shares on matching personas, not raw counts.

The Creative Angle Analyzer skill

One Claude skill that does what you just saw, on any brand. Paste Ad Library ads or an export, or connect Claude to Adge, and it returns the angle mix, a diversity score, the versioning trap, a persona x angle grid and three angle briefs.

Cadence: MonthlyRead onlySkill file: creative-angle-analyzerWorks with the 12-skill pack

Answers: How many real reasons to buy is this brand giving Meta, who does each one reach, and where is it just making the same ad again?

The skill instructions (SKILL.md)
---
name: creative-angle-analyzer
description: Classify every ad idea a brand runs on Meta by its creative angle (the argument for buying, not the format), map angles to personas, and score how diverse the mix is for Andromeda. Use when someone shares Ad Library ads, an ads export or a creative list and asks about angles, personas, creative diversity, Andromeda, Entity IDs, or "are we just making the same ad again".
---

# Creative Angle Analyzer

Andromeda, Meta's ad retrieval system, picks a few thousand candidate ads per person from tens of millions. Variants that look and say the same thing compete with each other for the same slot. A new hook, creator or crop on the same argument is a variant. A new angle is a new reason to buy, and it can reach a different person. This skill measures how many real angles a brand runs and how hard it works each one.

## Definitions (use these exactly)

- **Persona**: who the ad is for (a person with a situation and a want).
- **Angle**: the single argument the ad makes for why that person should buy now. One per idea.
- **Concept**: the story or scene that carries the angle (a skit, a review, a founder talk).
- **Execution**: format, creator, hook line, edit, crop, CTA. Changing only these never makes a new angle.

Test for a new angle: if you wrote the ad's argument as one sentence with the product name removed, would it be a different sentence? If not, it is the same angle.

## Angle taxonomy (use exactly these labels)

1. Problem & pain: names a specific problem the product fixes (bloating, low energy, poor sleep)
2. Desire & outcome: sells the end state, not the problem (glow, calm, strength)
3. Simplify the stack: replaces many products, steps or decisions with one
4. Value & offer: the deal is the argument (discount, free gift, bundle, trial, guarantee)
5. Authority & science: an expert, study, ingredient or mechanism carries the claim
6. Social proof: real customers, reviews, numbers of users, before/after
7. Celebrity & ambassador: a known name carries the claim
8. Us vs them: compares against a named or implied alternative
9. Life moment: a specific situation makes it relevant now (GLP-1, travel, new parent, midlife, season)
10. Identity & performance: who you become or belong to (athlete, high performer, professional)
11. Sensory & format: taste, texture, ritual, form factor is the reason
12. Objection buster: answers a doubt head on (skeptic turned fan, "I tried to hate it")
- No clear angle: product shown or unboxed with no argument. Count it; it is a finding.

## Steps

1. De-duplicate ads into ideas (same core visual or video and same concept = one idea). Keep each idea's number of ads (versions) and days live.
2. For each idea write one line: persona, angle sentence, angle label (one primary, at most one secondary), concept, execution.
3. Angle mix: per angle label count ideas, ads, share of ideas, share of ads, ads per idea, median days live, share of ideas live 30+ days.
4. Diversity score:
   - Distinct angles with at least 5% of ads.
   - Effective number of angles = 1 / sum(share of ads per angle squared). Under 4 is concentrated; 6+ is diverse.
   - Top 3 angles' share of ads. Over 70% is concentrated.
   - Share of ideas with No clear angle. Over 15% is waste.
5. Versioning vs staying power: flag angles with ads per idea above the brand average AND median days live below the brand median. That is volume going into variants Andromeda likely treats as one ad, on angles that are not sticking.
6. Persona x angle grid: rows = personas, columns = angles, cells = idea counts. Empty cells next to big personas are white space.
7. If a competitor is supplied, run steps 3 to 6 for it and show the differences in share of ads per angle.

## Output

- Scope line: brand, platform, window, number of ideas and ads, source
- KPI row: Ideas | Ads | Ads per idea | Effective angles | Top 3 angle share | No clear angle %
- Angle mix table, sorted by share of ads
- Versioning vs staying power: the flagged angles, one line each
- Persona x angle grid
- 3 angle briefs: a new angle (or an under-used one) for a named persona, each with the angle sentence, why now, and a first-3-seconds idea
- 3 bullet read, each with a basis label: (Data) from counts, (Adge data) for platform norms, (Inference) for your read

## Rules

- One angle per idea. If you need two, pick the one the first 3 seconds sells.
- Never call a format, creator, or hook style an angle.
- Days live is a proxy for a winner, not proof. Say so once.
- Ad Library data has no spend or results. Never present share of ads as share of spend.
- "Entity ID" is an industry term for how Andromeda groups similar ads, not a documented Meta field. Do not quote similarity thresholds as fact.
- No em dashes.
Tip

Run it on your own account first, then on your top two competitors with the same window. The angles they own and you do not are your briefs. Re-run monthly: a falling effective-angle score is an early warning before CPA moves.

When more angles is the wrong fix

SituationWhy angle diversity will not save itDo this instead
Small budgetEach angle needs enough delivery to learn. Spreading thin starves all of them.Run 3 to 5 strong angles, add one at a time.
Weak offer or product fitNew arguments for a product people do not want still lose.Fix the offer and landing page first.
Every ad looks identicalRetrieval reads visuals and audio too. A new angle in the same template may still cluster with the old ones.Change the concept and look along with the argument.
Angle is right, execution is weakThe argument never lands if the first 2 seconds fail.Keep the angle, test hooks.
Chasing a competitor's angleTheir angle may be a low-spend test nobody switched off.Use days live and versioning as signals, then test.

Frequently asked questions

What is Meta Andromeda?

Meta's machine learning system for ad retrieval, the first stage of delivery. It narrows every ad a person is eligible for down to a few thousand candidates before ranking and the auction. Meta introduced it in December 2024 and published a next-generation version in October 2026.

Is an Entity ID a real Meta metric?

Not as a documented field. It is a practitioner term for how Andromeda appears to group near-identical ads. Meta's October 2026 notes say the new system scores every eligible ad, so "one ticket per cluster" is a simplification. The practical effect still holds: near-identical ads score alike and compete for the same people.

What is the difference between an angle and a concept?

The angle is the argument (why buy). The concept is the story that carries it (a skit, a review, a founder talk). One angle can run through many concepts; a new concept on the same argument is not a new angle.

How many angles should a brand run?

Enough to cover your main personas with their real reason to buy. In the skill, an effective-angle score under 4 is concentrated and 6 or more is diverse. AG1 scores 6.1 in its most-versioned ideas.

Can I run the skill without Adge?

Yes. Paste ads from the Meta Ad Library or an Ads Manager export and Claude will classify them. Connected to Adge, it runs on every idea a brand has launched, with personas and days live already tagged.

Does share of ads mean share of spend?

No. Competitor data comes from public ad libraries, which show creative, not spend or results. Read share of ads as where a brand puts its creative effort.

Sources

Data: Adge Nexus (Meta public ad library), pulled 22 Nov 2026.

Get the Creative Angle Analyzer skill

Free. The SKILL.md, the AG1 vs IM8 example output and install notes, in one zip.

By continuing, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

Want this applied to your account?

20 minutes, no slides: your market, the first ads we'd make for you, and your pricing.

Get your ad ideas

More from the Journal